Front Porch Blog

Massive mountaintop removal mine threatens Clearfork Valley

April Jarocki and Appalachian Voices' Matt Hepler stand next to mining equipment next to the Hatfield Cemetery near Cooper Ridge Mine.

April Jarocki and Appalachian Voices’ Matt Hepler watch mining equipment next to the Hatfield Cemetery near Cooper Ridge Mine.

The energy supply of the nation has largely shifted towards natural gas in recent years and, slowly but surely, renewables are also gaining market share. These trends have at times been interpreted to mean that mountaintop removal coal mining is over. This is far from the truth.

The devastating practice of destroying entire mountains and disposing of mining-waste into headwater streams is still happening across the Appalachian region. For folks living beneath these mines, the assertion that mountaintop removal is over can feel like a slap in the face. Despite dynamics and shifts in energy markets, when there is a mountaintop removal mine above your community, the issue is as dire as ever.

The Clearfork Valley of Tennessee has been intensely surface-mined going back decades. As a result, the ridges and hillsides of Campbell and Claiborne counties display a patchwork of mining scars in various states of affliction and gradual healing. Some of these scars are pre-regulation Abandoned Mine Lands while others illustrate the failures of common reclamation standards. The area’s waterways are contaminated to varying degrees with metals, salts and sediment, and support far less aquatic life than they once did.

Now, Kopper Glo Mining is moving forward with a nearly 1,500-acre mountaintop removal mine on Cooper Ridge, dealing yet another massive blow to the ecology and communities of this beautiful and resilient area.

Agency missteps in the permitting process

Kopper Glo began operations on Cooper Ridge Mine this past spring, clearing initial, albeit insufficient, regulatory hurdles. Now the company is seeking a Phase II National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit required under the Clean Water Act for discharging pollutants into public waterways. The second phase allows the company to release higher levels of pollutants than allowable under the Phase I permit.

The Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation’s (TDEC) issuance of water pollution permits in phases is a notable problem. This allows the agency — whose mission includes “protecting and improving the quality of Tennessee’s air, land, and water through a responsible regulatory system” — to ignore the true total impacts of a mining operation on adjacent waterways by only considering portions of the mine’s impacts at any one time.

Another issue is that Kopper Glo and regulatory agencies consider this operation a “re-mining” project, suggesting that the area is already impacted by mining and that the Cooper Ridge mountaintop removal mine will serve to reclaim and improve previously mined areas. The truth is that only around one-third of the permitted area has been impacted by older strip mines. Rather than repair old scars of mining, the Cooper Ridge permit will simply triple the footprint of mining on this mountain.

Finally, Kopper Glo has a long history of violations at other mines in the area. Regulatory agencies like TDEC and the federal Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement should not be so quick to grant additional permits to a company that has consistently demonstrated either an inability or unwillingness to operate within the confines of the law.

What’s wrong with this mine?

Any surface mine of this size will have severe impacts on ecology and nearby communities. This is especially true in areas like East Tennessee, where headwater streams abound and where homes are crowded into narrow valleys often right at the toe of mining operations. Concerns include excessive runoff, sedimentation of streams, alterations to groundwater hydrology and the discharge of high levels of selenium and other harmful substances into waterways.

In addition to adverse impacts to ground and surface water, the Cooper Ridge mine threatens important local community and cultural assets. The permit boundary sits just a half-mile behind Clairfield Elementary School, presenting concerns for the health and safety of the students, teachers and community members engaged in activities at the school. The mine also surrounds the historic and still-in-use Hatfield Cemetery — an area where logging related to the mine has already occurred and where mine workers are now parking trucks and equipment.

Appalachian Voices, and many groups and citizens, are making these points to the agency:

  • Permitting in Phases: TDEC must consider all of the discharges from the entire proposed mine in a single permit process. By issuing water pollution permits in at least two separate phases, TDEC has failed to account for the full impact to the receiving streams.
  • Impacts of Re-Mining: TDEC should not assume that re-mining will lead to an overall decrease in pollution from the site. In fact, evidence suggests that streams in the Clear Fork watershed have only recently begun to recover from the pollution impacts of historic mining and that recent mining has started to reverse that trend.
  • Compliance History: The agencies should not reward a chronic violator with permits for a new surface mine. The permit application lists at least 17 notices of violation from OSM to Kopper Glo for its other coal mining operations in less than three years, including many violations related to water quality.
  • Cumulative Impacts: Permitting authorities must address the cumulative impacts of water pollution discharged from all existing and proposed strip mines in the Clear Fork watershed before issuing any new permits.
  • Selenium: The draft permit violates the Clean Water Act because it fails to fully evaluate the reasonable potential of discharges from the mine to violate water quality standards for selenium. Given that selenium is known to be present in variable concentrations in coal seams in Tennessee, TDEC should require the applicant to conduct and report representative core sampling to determine whether selenium is likely to be present in the coal to be mined from the site.
  • Groundwater Impacts: This mine would affect groundwater because it will change the hydrology of the east side of Cooper Ridge and release pollutants now contained in the coal and the overburden at the site. Groundwater and surface water resources are closely connected in this area. There are at least seven households and two churches that use springs or wells for their water supply.
  • Impacts on Sensitive Species: The blackside dace, a freshwater fish, is protected as threatened under the federal Endangered Species Act, in part because of pollution from surface coal mining. The Cooper Ridge mine will discharge polluted runoff water to tributaries of the Clear Fork, an important corridor that blackside dace use seasonally to seek spawning habitat in smaller streams. Blackside dace are extremely intolerant of elevated conductivity levels caused by dissolved solids from polluted mining runoff. Any discharge permit for the mine must impose limits on conductivity to avoid further harm to blackside dace.
  • Community Cemetery: This mine will be near family cemeteries which must be protected. Community members must be able to access family cemeteries on Cooper Ridge, and we ask that the deep mine portal be moved further than 100 feet away from the Hatfield Cemetery.
  • Economics: Tourism is important to the current and future economy of Tennessee. The Tackett Creek Wildlife Management area surrounds the proposed Cooper Ridge mine. This area has great potential for increased ecotourism that can benefit Tennessee’s economy more than another strip mine.

A Virginia native and resident of Wise County, Willie is no stranger to the challenges Appalachia faces and he has organized for several environmental and social justice groups in the region. He is one of Appalachian Voices' Central Appalachian Campaign Coordinators.

TAGS:
4 COMMENTS
  1. Karla Klueter says:

    Thankyou to ALL who keep fighting to STOP Mountain Top Removal! Why won’t Congress and our “president” STOP THIS OUT OF CONTROL B.S.???$$$$$$ ……and I cannot believe that more concerned citizens and neighbors locally won’t fight..but I understand their hands are tied!!!!!Having to watch their beautiful environment and countryside continuously being raped, would be the most depressing of all…compare all the tornadoes, hurricanes, etc., these natural occurring events are part of the earths course of natural events. But THIS GREEDY, SELFISH RAPE OF OUR EARTH HAS GOT TO STOP NOW!!!!!Start looking for LEADERSHIP that will STOP this insane RAPE OF OUR MOTHER. Thankyou for letting me vent. I’m not wealthy, so I cannot give money to help you out. If so, I would buy out all this bullshit! But I, like most, struggle to make ends meet…but knowing there are people fighting to change this RAPE of our Mother Earth, is All we can do…Thankyou for letting me vent….if God can hear ALL our prayers, we have to believe CHANGE CAN HAPPEN…but MOUNTAINTOPS DON’T GROW BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  2. Janet Ward says:

    When will we ever learn…
    This is a good article and I’m planning to use the talking points and info to send letters to several agencies. Mountain top removal continues to disrupt ions old natural systems and human communities.

  3. Sarah Hincks says:

    How long is the comment period? Can I still send comments ?

  4. Jimmy Freeman says:

    This needs to stop for so many reasons. But for those that only see DOLLAR SIGNS, how about this. My wife and I are looking for where to retire. And the Appalachian mountains of Tennessee are a strong contender. But this strikes fear in our hearts. Why would someone move into an area where this is being done? Or could happen in your area in the future? What is the economic impact of thousands of retirees not coming to your state? We have a seven figure 401k and many soon to be retirees, like us, can afford to retire anywhere they want! As a group we will have a huge impact wherever we go! And where we don’t go will be negatively impacted! You may be killing the Golden Goose of the future for one gold egg from a dying industry! How long can you poison your state without poisoning your tourism and the hope of attracting retirees and our MONEY? Politicians need to take the blinders off and look at the BIG PICTURE! You can only have mine for a few years, you can have a mountain forever!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*