Front Porch Blog
Despite strong opposition from local residents, the Cumberland County Board of Supervisors voted 3-1 to approve a conditional use permit for Dominion Energy’s proposed 3-gigawatt methane gas plant on Oct. 20. Cumberland County, Virginia, residents raised serious concerns about the massive gas plant’s impact on their rural community and underscored how many critical questions remain unanswered.
Cumberland County Board of Supervisors Chairman John Newman, a retired Dominion employee currently receiving pension benefits, recused himself from the vote regarding the conditional use permit for the gas plant. Shortly afterwards, on Nov. 10, 2026, Newman resigned from the board citing the conflict of interest in his resignation letter.
Dominion has yet to identify a source for the millions of gallons of water the gas plant would need for cooling or announce the route of the methane gas pipeline needed to supply it. Residents also questioned whose land and property could be affected by these developments.
If built, it would be the largest gas plant in Virginia and one of the largest in the country. Dominion says the plant is needed to keep up with growing demand from data centers. In filings with the State Corporation Commission, Dominion said data centers will account for 99% of the utility’s peak electricity demand by 2030. While the plant would help power data centers, the nearby community would be left dealing with the health risks and pollution. The Southern Environmental Law Center commissioned a study of the gas plant’s potential health impacts, which are summarized below.
Air pollution from the Cumberland gas plant will harm the health of nearby communities
Gas-fired power plants are significant sources of fine particulate matter air pollution, called PM2.5, which is invisible to the naked eye and 20-30 times smaller than a human hair. Fine particulate matter is one of the most harmful forms of air pollution in the world. It can get deep into the bloodstream, and increased exposure raises the risk of heart attack, stroke and premature death. Dominion’s proposed power plant in Cumberland County would emit an estimated 227 tons of PM2.5 annually, in addition to hundreds of tons of other pollutants that contribute to additional PM2.5 formation downwind.
Residents in northern Cumberland County and neighboring Powhatan County would face the largest increases of PM2.5 pollution and the greatest health risks from the plant. Air pollution would also have negative public health impacts in communities around Richmond, only 40 miles downwind of the facility. The added PM2.5 exposure from the plant is expected to cause illnesses and about 3 to 7 premature deaths each year. Over the plant’s expected 30-year lifespan, that could add up to between 97 and 214 premature deaths.
Economic costs of the Cumberland plant to Virginians
The economic damages associated with these health impacts would range from $61 to $118 million annually, costing Virginians as much as $3.6 billion over the plant’s 30-year lifespan. These health impacts could include asthma, cardiovascular and respiratory illnesses, leading to missed work days and premature death. The report found that these health impacts and related economic costs could still occur even if the plant meets all national air quality standards.
What’s next for Dominion’s proposed gas plant
Despite receiving a conditional use permit from Cumberland County, several unanswered questions remain. First, there is no agreement in place regarding a cooling water source for the massive gas plant. Dominion proposes to use the brand-new Cobbs Creek Reservoir in Cumberland County — a water source that only came online in the last year. Complicating the matter, the reservoir is owned by Henrico County, which developed it over the last 20 years to protect regional water supplies during drought. Only an informal agreement exists between the counties, which currently allows Henrico to sell water to Cumberland.
Dominion has not revealed the potential water discharge location and the proposed locations of water and gas pipelines. Finally, Dominion still needs to obtain additional state permits, including an air permit from the Department of Environmental Quality and a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity from the State Corporation Commission. Appalachian Voices will continue working with local residents to ensure that their concerns are heard.
PREVIOUS
NEXT
Leave a comment
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Leave a Comment