TAKE ACTION

The Forest Service wants to turn WV national forest over to a coal company. Don’t let them!

Congress has prohibited coal mining activity in national forests, with very few exceptions. But the US Forest Service is taking extraordinary measures to open a portion of the Monongahela National Forest (known locally as “the Mon”) near Richwood and Lewisburg, West Virginia, to coal trucks. This would enable a new and already chronically non-compliant coal company to clear-cut and strip hundreds of acres along the border of the national forest. 

A pair of affiliated coal companies called Clearco and Aurevo control 3,600 acres of strip mines and associated infrastructure in the Cherry River watershed in West Virginia’s Greenbrier County. For years, these mines have polluted the Cherry with heavy metals and sediment. This threatens pristine trout waters, the endangered candy darter and downstream communities that depend on clean rivers for recreation, tourism and drinking water. The Cherry is also part of the Gauley River watershed, which is famous for top-tier whitewater rafting. 

Now Clearco wants to take over a 1.2 mile stretch of a public Forest Service road in order to haul coal and equipment through the Monongahela National Forest. This would close approximately 280 acres of public land to hikers, hunters, anglers and others for at least 10 years so that the coal company can treat it as its own private property.

The Forest Service published a draft permit that would hand a portion of the Mon over to Clearco, despite conservation groups providing a thorough analysis of unacceptable environmental and legal implications, and despite thousands of public comments. 

We now have one more opportunity to register our objection to this horrible plan. Please take action by November 29, and stay tuned! If the Forest Service finalizes this permit, Appalachian Voices and our partners intend to keep fighting. Our clean water and public lands are too important to stand down.

Petition:

To Amy Albright, USFS NEPA Planner

Ms. Albright,

Thank you for considering my comments with regards to Clearco Processing Corporation’s request for a Special Use Permit for Forest Roads 249 and 233. The Monongahela National Forest is a local, state and national treasure, and no portion of it should be entrusted to a coal company that is new, unproven, and already in chronic non-compliance with environmental requirements. 

As someone who cares about the Monongahela National Forest, I am asking that you reject Clearco Processing Corporation’s request to use Forest Roads 249 and 223 for coal hauling and servicing coal mining operations. Rejecting this request would serve the community and our public lands in a number of ways, enumerated below.

Give the public a meaningful opportunity to respond to the supporting science. This process has been rushed and the public has not had adequate time to review and comment on the biological and aquatic analyses of the proposed Special Use Permit. It would be appropriate for the USFS to reject Clearco’s application, after which the company can re-apply if it chooses, and USFS can (and should) afford the public more time to scrutinize the proposal. Alternatively, simply extending this comment period by 60 more days would serve a similar purpose.

Keep public lands accessible. The proposed closure of part of FR249 for ten years would restrict public access to surrounding national forest lands in order to accommodate a private coal operation.

Protect Richwood’s drinking water. FR223 runs beside Bear Run, which drains into the North Fork Cherry River, Richwood’s drinking-water source. Transporting fuel and mining chemicals along this route creates spill risks that deserve serious scrutiny.

Protect endangered candy darters and native brook trout. Sediment from hauling and road maintenance can degrade stream habitat. The Forest Service must satisfy its Endangered Species Act obligations, including ensuring its authorization will not jeopardize listed species or destroy or adversely modify designated critical habitat.

Account for existing damage. The history of failed erosion controls and coal spills under the previous operator has produced sediment problems in Bear Run, adversely impacting aquatic habitats. Promises of future maintenance do not establish that another decade of industrial traffic will adequately protect these streams, but denying Clearco’s request to continue to impact the Bear Run watershed will give this stream a chance to recover from past impacts.

Honor the forest plan and the public interest. Handing over a portion of the national forest and USFS roads to Clearco would be in conflict with the Monongahela Forest Plan. It would also violate applicable water-quality requirements and pose serious risks to public health and safety. Private commercial interests do not override these safeguards.

Enforce federal mining restrictions. Clearco must demonstrate that it has “valid existing rights,” as defined in the Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act, to operate within the Monongahela on FR249 and FR223. A Forest Service Special Use Permit issued nearly 50 years after SMCRA’s enactment does not satisfy this criteria, as is clear according to the letter of the law. But Clearco — just like South Fork Coal before it — intends to present such a permit as a rationale for requesting a “valid existing rights” determination. Rejecting the company’s request for a Special Use Permit is not only consistent with the applicable forest plan, but also upholds the nearly 50-year-old ban on mining and related activity within the Mon.

Thank you for considering my input on the management of our public lands and protection of upstream waters.