Skip to content

Audit Finds Mine Safety Penalties Ineffective

A federal audit of the U.S. Mine Safety and Health Administration, released in August 2019, found no evidence to support a correlation between payment of mine safety penalties and the safety of mine operations over 18 years.

Wes Addington, executive director of the nonprofit Appalachian Citizens Law Center, told National Public Radio that “penalties just aren’t high enough to deter bad behavior.”

The auditors looked at coal, metal and nonmetal mines together.

The auditors recommended that MSHA hold mine operators accountable for their safety record by not allowing them to open new mines if they have outstanding penalties. However, MSHA claims they do not have the legal authority to do this. Auditors also recommended that MSHA develop ways to measure the effectiveness of penalties, but MSHA expressed difficulties, telling NPR that fines are one of many variables to make mines safe.

West Virginia Gov. Jim Justice and his family own the most delinquent mine companies in the country. The companies owed $4.7 million in unpaid mine safety penalties as of September, which accounts for nearly 10 percent of all mine-related delinquent debt in the United States, according to information disclosed by MSHA.

In May, MSHA and the U.S. Department of Justice sued the Justice family for failure to pay. In July, lawyers for the Justice family filed a motion to dismiss, which federal prosecutors refused. — By Hannah McAlister

AV-mountainBorder-tan-medium1

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Leave a Comment





sink your teeth into the best shark tank cbd gummies for diabetes a comprehensive guide to managing unlock a deeper state of calm with exhale wellness cbd gummies the ultimate natural solution for st the best cbd gummy for diabetes unlocking relief with natural ingredients is cbd and hemp gummies the same debunking the myth and choosing the right product for your needs what is the best cbd gummy for sleep unlocking the secrets of a restful night 39 s slumber unwind and recharge with medallion green cbd gummies amazon the ultimate relaxation experience find calm cbd gummies near me the ultimate solution for relaxation and anxiety relief finding the best libido booster for men a comprehensive guide to enhancing male libido 219 erectile dysfunction pills that work a comprehensive guide 31855 gummies en a guide for londoners in 2023 how to choose the best cbd gummies for sex the best cbd gummies for women 39 s libido unlocking a healthier happier you 18722 unleash your potential the power of gummy cbd viagra for men obtaining free erectile dysfunction samples a comprehensive guide to effective treatment op the science behind rapid lean keto gummies what gummies did kelly clarkson take keto gummies shark tank ingredients the secret to weight loss success with divine labs revolutionize your keto journey with keto f1 gummies unlock the power of weight loss and wellness revolutionize your weight loss journey with apple cider vinegar gummies a game changing solution fo gummies that burn fat while you sleep a comprehensive guide 539 dr oz keto gummies unlock the power of a keto diet with delicious easy to take gummies